Year, Player, School
1980, Debbie Walker, SB LaSalle
1984, Sharon Versyp, Mishawaka (Miss Basketball)
1986, Melissa Standley, SB St. Joseph's
1993, Tracey Pearson, SB Adams
1996, Jenea Skeeters, Mishawaka
1997, Constance Murdock, SB Clay
2000, Jessica Reiter, Penn
2001, Jacqueline Batteast, SB Washington
2003, Suntana Granderson, SB Riley
2005, Aimee Litka, SB St. Joseph's
2005, Jerri Taylor, SB Washington
2006, Melissa Lechlitner, SB St. Joseph's
2007, Sydney Smallbone, SB St. Joseph's
2007, Kristen Dockery, SB St. Joseph's
2007, Ashley Varner, SB Washington
2008, Emily Phillips, SB Washington
2009, Skylar Diggins, SB Washington (Miss Basketball)
2009, Lily Svete, Penn
2012, Alex Morton, Penn
2013, Caroline Buhr, Penn
2014, Tiara Murphy, SB Washington (junior All-Star)
2015, Tiara Murphy, SB Washington
2015, Madeline Raster, SB St. Joseph
2016, Camryn Buhr, Penn
2017, Nicole Konieczny, SB St. Joseph
